Peer Review Process
A detailed overview of how manuscripts are evaluated, reviewed, and published at AJHCS
Review Model Overview
New submissions use single-blind peer review. Reviewers can see authors’ names and affiliations; authors do not see reviewers’ identities. Earlier submissions retain their existing identity handling.
Our review process follows the guidelines established by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and adheres to the principles of the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE).
Review Stages & Timeline
Each manuscript passes through the following stages from submission to publication. We target a first editorial decision within 14 business days from submission and publication within 4–12 weeks from submission to publication, including review, revisions, and production.
- Day 0
Manuscript Submission
Authors submit their manuscript via the AJHCS online portal. The submission must include all required components: title page, manuscript, abstract, keywords, author declarations, and any supplementary materials.
- Scope and completeness checks
Editorial Triage & Desk Review
The Editor-in-Chief or a Section Editor conducts an initial assessment for scope, completeness, methodological soundness, and adherence to submission guidelines. Manuscripts that fall outside the journal scope or do not meet minimum quality standards may receive a desk decision at this stage with editorial feedback.
- Subject expertise and conflict checks
Reviewer Assignment
The handling editor identifies and invites 2-3 independent reviewers with relevant subject matter expertise. Reviewers are selected based on domain knowledge, prior review quality, and absence of conflicts of interest. If the initial invitees decline, alternative reviewers are identified.
- Deadline stated in the review invitation
Single-Blind Peer Review
Reviewers evaluate the manuscript against AJHCS evaluation criteria: methodological rigor, originality, clarity, relevance to healthcare strategy, ethical compliance, and statistical validity. Each reviewer submits a structured report with a recommendation (accept, minor revision, major revision, or reject) and detailed feedback for the authors.
- Target: 14 business days from submission
Editorial Decision
The handling editor synthesizes reviewer reports and makes a decision: accept as-is, accept with minor revisions, request major revisions and re-review, or reject. The editorial decision records the outcome and shares editorial feedback and reviewer comments when available. Delivery follows the author workspace and configured notification channels.
- Deadline stated in the decision letter
Author Revision (if applicable)
Authors address reviewer and editor comments in a revised manuscript accompanied by a point-by-point response letter. For minor revisions, the editor may make the final decision. For major revisions, the manuscript is returned to the original reviewers for re-evaluation.
- After acceptance and author proof review
Copyediting & Production
Accepted manuscripts undergo professional copyediting for grammar, style, and formatting consistency. Authors review galley proofs and approve the final version. Citation metadata and any registered DOI are checked before publication.
- After publication checks and proof approval
Online Publication
The final article is published on the AJHCS website under a CC-BY 4.0 license with full open access. External discovery and indexing follow each service’s own process and are not guaranteed at publication.
Reviewer Qualifications
AJHCS maintains a diverse pool of qualified peer reviewers drawn from academia, healthcare systems, consulting, and government agencies. Reviewers are selected for each manuscript based on their specific expertise relative to the submission’s subject matter.
Academic Credentials
Reviewers typically hold a doctoral degree (PhD, DrPH, MD, JD, or equivalent) in healthcare administration, public health, health policy, health economics, nursing, medicine, or a related discipline.
Domain Expertise
Demonstrated expertise in one or more areas within the journal scope, evidenced by a track record of peer-reviewed publications, academic appointments, or significant professional experience in healthcare strategy and leadership.
Research Experience
Active involvement in research, either as an independent investigator, principal investigator, or co-investigator on funded research projects. Familiarity with both quantitative and qualitative research methodologies is valued.
Professional Standing
Current affiliation with an accredited academic institution, healthcare system, research organization, consulting firm, or government agency. Reviewers must be in good standing with their institution and free of sanctions.
Ethical Commitment
Willingness to adhere to COPE guidelines, maintain confidentiality of reviewed manuscripts, disclose any potential conflicts of interest, and provide fair, constructive, and timely feedback.
Review Metrics
Review our editorial policy and available measurements below. Timing values are targets from submission; unavailable measurements are identified explicitly.
Timing targets: These intervals are policy targets, not measured averages or guarantees. Individual manuscript timelines depend on reviewer availability, revision complexity, and submission volume.
Conflict of Interest Policy
AJHCS requires all parties involved in the peer review process—authors, reviewers, and editors—to disclose any potential conflicts of interest that could compromise the objectivity or integrity of the review.
For Authors
Authors must disclose all financial and non-financial relationships that could be perceived as influencing the research. This includes funding sources, employment, consultancies, stock ownership, honoraria, paid expert testimony, patent applications, and personal relationships. Declarations of interest must be submitted with the manuscript.
For Reviewers
Reviewers must decline to review any manuscript where they have a conflict of interest, including: personal or professional relationship with any author; financial interest in the outcome; recent collaboration (within 3 years) with any author; affiliation with the same institution as any author; or competitive interests that could bias their assessment. Reviewers must notify the editor immediately if a conflict is identified after accepting a review.
For Editors
Editors must recuse themselves from handling any manuscript where they have a personal, professional, or financial conflict of interest. In such cases, the manuscript is reassigned to another editor. The Editor-in-Chief serves as the final arbiter in cases of disputed conflicts.
Decision Criteria
Following peer review, the handling editor makes one of the following decisions based on reviewer recommendations and editorial assessment.
Accept
The manuscript is accepted for publication as submitted or with only minor copyediting changes. This decision is rare on first submission.
Minor Revision
The manuscript requires small changes (clarifications, additional references, minor restructuring) before acceptance. The editor typically makes the final decision without re-review.
Major Revision
Substantial changes are required (additional analysis, restructuring, methodological clarification). The revised manuscript will be sent back to the original reviewers for re-evaluation.
Reject
The manuscript is not suitable for publication in AJHCS. Reasons may include lack of originality, methodological flaws, insufficient relevance to the journal scope, or irremediable quality issues. Authors receive an editorial decision with feedback appropriate to the review stage.
Editorial Independence
The final decision rests with the handling editor and is based on the totality of reviewer feedback, the manuscript’s scholarly contribution, and alignment with the journal’s mission. Reviewer recommendations are advisory; the editor may reach a different conclusion when the reviews are conflicting or when additional factors warrant consideration. All decisions are made independently, without influence from external parties, funders, or advertisers.
Editorial Decisions and Appeals
To ask about an editorial decision or an appeal, contact the editorial office at editor@ajhcs.org.
Join Our Reviewer Community
We are always seeking qualified reviewers with expertise in healthcare strategy, health policy, hospital administration, and related fields. If you are interested in contributing to the peer review process, please contact us.
Contact reviewers@ajhcs.orgQuestions about our peer review process? Contact the editorial office at editor@ajhcs.org. For reviewer guidelines and evaluation criteria, see our Reviewer Guidelines.