Skip to main content

Reviewer Guidelines

Standards and expectations for peer reviewers contributing to the integrity of AJHCS.

Our Review Philosophy

New submissions use single-blind peer review. Reviewers can see authors’ names and affiliations; authors do not see reviewers’ identities. Earlier submissions retain their existing identity handling.

Our editorial practices are guided by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) guidelines. We are committed to upholding the highest standards of integrity, fairness, and transparency in all aspects of the publication process.

We value constructive, developmental feedback that helps authors strengthen their work. Reviews should identify both merits and areas for improvement, offering specific and actionable guidance rather than vague criticism.

Evaluation Criteria

Reviewers are asked to assess manuscripts across the following dimensions. Not all criteria will apply equally to every submission type.

Methodological Rigor

Is the research design appropriate for the question posed? Are the methods clearly described and reproducible? Are limitations acknowledged?

Originality and Contribution

Does the manuscript offer new insights, frameworks, or evidence? Does it advance the field of healthcare strategy in a meaningful way?

Clarity and Organization

Is the manuscript well-structured and logically organized? Is the writing clear, concise, and appropriate for a scholarly audience?

Relevance to Healthcare Strategy

Does the work address a significant question in healthcare strategy, policy, administration, or related disciplines? Is it timely and applicable?

Ethical Compliance

Does the research adhere to ethical standards? Are conflicts of interest disclosed? Is informed consent and IRB approval documented where applicable?

Statistical Validity

Where applicable, are statistical methods appropriate and correctly applied? Are results presented clearly with effect sizes and confidence intervals?

Review Process Timeline

Our target is a first editorial decision within 14 business days of submission. This is the journal’s author-facing first-decision target, not a reviewer deadline. Each reviewer’s deadline is stated in the invitation.

Invitation Sent

Editors identify and invite qualified reviewers based on expertise and availability.

Day 0

Accept or Decline

Reviewers confirm availability and absence of conflicts by the deadline in their invitation.

As stated in the invitation

Review Period

Reviewers evaluate the manuscript using our structured evaluation criteria and submit their report.

Deadline stated in the invitation

Decision Communicated

The editorial team synthesizes reviews and communicates a decision to the author.

Agreed with the editor

Reviewer Responsibilities

Peer review is foundational to scholarly publishing. Reviewers are expected to uphold these core responsibilities.

Confidentiality

Treat all manuscripts as confidential documents. Do not share, discuss, or distribute any aspect of the submission with others without editorial permission.

Objectivity

Provide an impartial assessment based on scholarly merit. Personal criticism of the author is never appropriate. Focus on the quality of the work.

Timeliness

Complete reviews within the agreed-upon timeframe. If you are unable to meet the deadline, notify the editor as soon as possible so alternative arrangements can be made.

Constructive Feedback

Offer specific, actionable suggestions that help the author improve the manuscript. Identify both strengths and areas for improvement.

Conflict of Interest Disclosure

Decline invitations to review if you have a personal, financial, or professional relationship with the author, or if you cannot provide an unbiased assessment.

Interested in Reviewing?

We welcome applications from qualified researchers, practitioners, and academics with expertise in healthcare strategy and related fields. Join our reviewer community and contribute to advancing scholarship in the discipline.

Contact Us at reviewers@ajhcs.org